Sunday, August 9, 2009

Review by Alex- Touch

Touch by Francine Prose

What really happened at the back of the bus?

Did they, or didn't they?

Did she, or didn't she?

Something happened to fourteen-year-old Maisie Willard-something involving her three friends, all boys. But their stories don't match, and the rumors spin out of control. Then other people get involved . . . the school, the parents, the lawyers. The incident at the back of the bus becomes the center of Maisie's life and the talk of the school, and, horribly, it becomes news. With just a few words and a touch, the kids and their community are changed forever.

From nationally acclaimed author Francine Prose comes an unforgettable story about the difficulties of telling the truth, the consequences of lying, and the most dangerous twist of all-the possibility that you yourself will come to believe something that you know isn't true.

Touch has a really good premise. I like the description, reading about the mystery of what happened that fateful day on the bus. But... the book fell flat for me. The description on the cover flap is the high point- the actual novel is more meh.

The writing is good. It sounds young, it's clipped with short sentences, but that's the point (I'm assuming). Maisie is, after all, only 14. She's not some wise-old adult. She doesn't have a mature voice, and that's fine. Although sometimes, Maisie would come to some revelation, and would try to be wise. I didn't think that really worked, but it was only a few times, so it wasn't too bad.

The characters aren't bad. But they're not all that interesting either. Maisie tries to be tough- and for the most part, she handles everything pretty well. But she's immature and tends to wallow in her pity. She's somewhat close-minded, as she can't seem to understand that her step-mother isn't really all that bad and actually is trying to help in her own way. (Or at least, I think so.) Maisie has 3 childhood friends, all boys. Two of them aren't very important and don't have any personality but that they can be rude and well, like young teenage boys. Shakes, on the other hand, is distinguished by the fact that he has some slight problems. He doesn't walk properly, he has to think before he speaks, he shakes and twitches, which is where his nickname came from.

The ending was a split between predictable and unexpected. Mostly predictable, although some things were a surprise. I guess though, that's life. The ending is realistic and resolved, but it doesn't feel complete. I was a bit put out at the ending. But then again, I had to force myself to finish this book. I feel like there was supposed to be this major twist- Maisie figuring out the truth- but it was so obvious it was coming, that I wasn't very interested or stunned.

Overall, Touch is decent. But it's by no means amazing. It's a tale of a girl who maybe something happened to on the back of a bus, and the discovery of figuring out the truth. Read if you find that you're interested in the description, but don't get your hopes up all that high, is what I say. The novel isn't nearly captivating enough to live up to the description.













9 comments:

  1. Lovely review! I like the description too. It sounds very interesting. I don't think I'll read it though considering I have a whole bunch of other books waiting for me at the library. You had to force yourself to finish the book? Yikes. That's not very good. I hate doing that even though that's the only way to give your complete thoughts on a book.

    haha. I really like your shelf ratings, they're very original!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like this review, in that it's honest. I think maybe I would be interested in this book if I didn't have a million other things on my TBR. Thanks to your review, I won't actively seek this book out. :-)
    Sometimes it helps to be discerning LOL.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice, honest review. I want to read this book. Maybe I'll just get it from the library(:

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice review. The ending sounds kinda like what I felt about What I Saw and How I Lied.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hm.. this sounds interesting. Your review is good. I like that you told it how it is, and you were honest. I might just read it.

    -Arielle.

    ReplyDelete
  6. great blog. i'm following you now. check out/follow mine. i have all things books...
    nice seeing you.
    xo

    ReplyDelete
  7. Aw, I wanted to read this but I keep hearing how it's just average. Thanks for the honest review :)

    -Briana

    ReplyDelete
  8. Stop by my blog I have a surprise for you!

    http://neverendingshelf.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. Interesting review, Alex. From the description, I thought the premise sounded really strong too. I appreciate the honesty though!

    ReplyDelete

Say anything! We'd love to hear what you think. :)

 
Site Meter